Back to journal
Industry News

How to Hire an SEO Agency: 12 Questions to Ask Before You Sign

Ask every SEO agency the same 12 questions, in writing, before you sign. The answers show how they work, how they report and whether they will be honest when results are slow. Here is the list, built on Google's own guidance on hiring an SEO, plus the red flags to watch for.

JT
James Thornton
Senior SEO Strategist
13 min read
November 19, 2026

Hiring an SEO agency means trusting someone else's judgment on a channel that is slow, hard to verify and easy to oversell. You can't see most of the work, results take months, and a bad provider can do real damage before you notice.

Here is our direct answer on how to hire an SEO agency. Ask the questions below, in writing, to every agency you consider. The answers show how they work, how they report and whether they will be honest with you when results are slow. A good agency will welcome these questions. A weak one will dodge them.

We built this list around Google's own guidance on hiring an SEO, which Google last updated in June 2026, and added what we see businesses overlook.

A business team at a table with laptops and a growth chart, reviewing a clipboard together
Ask every agency the same questions in writing, then compare the answers side by side.

Do you need an SEO agency at all?

It's a fair question, and Google answers it plainly. Its guidance says that if you run a small local business, you can probably do much of the work yourself, and it recommends starting with its SEO Starter Guide. Google also says a great time to hire is during a site redesign or new site launch, the earlier the better, so the site is built to be search-friendly from the start.

In our view, hiring makes sense when you lack the time, when the work needs skills you don't have (technical fixes, content production, local or authority building), or when something has gone wrong, like a traffic drop or a migration. If you're only claiming your Google Business Profile and asking customers for reviews, you may not need an agency yet.

What should you prepare before you talk to anyone?

Three preparations make every conversation more useful:

  • Define the goal in business terms. "More booked jobs" or "more qualified leads" is better than "rank higher."
  • Know your baseline. Check your Google Search Console, GA4 and Google Business Profile performance so you can judge progress later.
  • Set a budget range and a decision-maker. It saves time on both sides.

The 12 questions to ask before you sign

1. What exactly will you do each month, and what will I receive?

SEO proposals often hide behind words like "optimization" and "strategy." Ask for deliverables in writing: audits, technical fixes, pages, content, profile work, link outreach and reports, plus who does each.

  • A good answer: a scoped list tied to your priorities, with clear owners and timing.
  • Red flag: vague promises, "proprietary" methods they can't explain, or a package that looks identical for every client.

2. Do you guarantee rankings or results?

Google is blunt on this. Its guidance says no one can guarantee a number-one ranking and warns against SEOs who claim a "special relationship" with Google or advertise "priority submit." It adds that if an SEO guarantees first place, you should find someone else.

  • A good answer: an honest explanation of what they can control (the quality and timing of the work) and what they can't (Google's decisions and your competitors).
  • Red flag: guaranteed rankings, traffic or leads, or "money-back" terms with fine print that make them impossible to claim.

3. How will you measure success, and what will you report?

Ask which numbers, from which sources, how often. For most businesses the right measures are leads, calls, form fills and booked jobs, backed by Search Console clicks and impressions, GA4 and Google Business Profile performance.

Pay attention to where data comes from. Google's guidance notes that third-party tools don't have access to Google's internal ranking data. Rank trackers and AI visibility tools can be useful, but they are estimates, so a good agency labels them that way.

  • A good answer: reporting tied to business outcomes, with measured data separated from estimates.
  • Red flag: reports built only on keyword positions or "traffic" with no link to leads or revenue.

4. What results should I expect, and in what timeframe?

This is one of Google's own suggested questions, and it exposes unrealistic sales pitches fast. SEO is slow. Ahrefs' 2025 study of one million new pages found only 1.74% reached Google's top 10 within a year, though 40.82% of the pages that did got there within a month. That data covers new pages on any topic, not local results, but the lesson holds: results take months, and timelines vary with competition and your site's history.

1.74%
Of new pages reached Google's top 10 within a year
40.82%
Of those got there within a month
1M
New pages in the Ahrefs 2025 study
  • A good answer: ranges, not promises, plus what you'll see in the first 90 days in terms of work completed, not rankings.
  • Red flag: "page one in 30 days."

5. Can you show me relevant work and connect me with references?

Google suggests asking for examples of previous work and success stories, and checking business references. Ask past clients whether the agency was easy to work with, communicated well and produced useful results.

  • A good answer: two or three examples with context (what the goal was, what changed, over what period), and references you can call.
  • Red flag: screenshots of rankings for obscure terms, testimonials with no names, or "confidential" for every client.

6. What is your experience in my industry and my market?

Another question from Google's list. A local contractor, a multi-location clinic, an ecommerce store and a SaaS company need very different SEO. Local businesses depend heavily on Google Business Profile, reviews and local pages. Online stores depend on product and category structure.

  • A good answer: specific observations about your market after a quick look, and questions about your customers and competitors.
  • Red flag: a generic pitch, or an audit that looks like a template.

7. How do you build links and authority?

Google's guidance says you should never have to link to an SEO, and warns against link popularity schemes and submitting your site to thousands of search engines. It also notes that techniques violating Google's spam policies can reduce your site's presence or remove it from the index.

  • A good answer: earning relevant links and mentions through digital PR, local sponsorships, partnerships, original data or useful resources, with examples of where links came from.
  • Red flag: link packages sold by the number, guaranteed domain-authority scores, "private blog networks" or bulk directory submissions.

8. How do you use AI, and how do you approach AI search?

Ask two things. First, how AI is used in content production, and who reviews and edits it. Second, what they do for visibility in AI search, often sold as "GEO" or "AEO."

Google's guidance tells you to check whether an SEO's advice on optimizing for AI experiences aligns with its official guidance on generative AI features, and to compare third-party audit recommendations against official documentation.

  • A good answer: human review and original input in content, advice that cites official documentation, and honesty that nobody can guarantee AI citations.
  • Red flag: mass-produced pages, promises of guaranteed AI mentions, or "secret" markup that supposedly unlocks visibility.

9. Who owns the accounts, content and data?

You should. Your Google Analytics, Search Console, Tag Manager, Google Business Profile, domain and hosting should sit in accounts under your control, with the agency added as a user.

Google adds a useful point for the audit stage: if an SEO offers an audit, grant only read access to Search Console at that stage, not write access. And if an SEO has FTP or similar access to your site, Google says they should be willing to explain every change they make.

  • A good answer: you keep admin access, and changes are documented.
  • Red flag: analytics or profiles registered in the agency's name, or a site that can't be exported if you leave.

10. Who will work on my account, and how will we communicate?

Google suggests asking how you can expect to communicate and whether the SEO will share all changes and the reasoning behind their recommendations. Also ask who does the actual work, and whether any of it is outsourced.

  • A good answer: a named contact, a regular cadence (such as a monthly report and call) and a change log.
  • Red flag: a senior pitch followed by silence, or answers that avoid who does the work.

11. What does it cost, what's included, and what are the contract terms?

SEO pricing varies a lot because the market does. Ahrefs' survey of 439 SEO providers reported agency retainers averaging about $3,209 a month, with $501 to $2,000 the most common band, and most providers billing by monthly retainer. Backlinko's survey puts the typical range at $1,000 to $2,500. The two disagree because they sample different parts of the market, so use them as a sanity check, not a target.

Ask what's included, whether setup fees apply, whether content, link costs, tools and ad spend are separate, the minimum term, the notice needed to cancel and how scope changes are handled. This is general information, not legal advice, so have a professional review any contract.

  • A good answer: a clear scope-to-price match, and a way out if it isn't working.
  • Red flag: a price far below the market paired with big promises, a long lock-in with no review point, or surprise add-ons.

12. What do you need from us, and what happens if results stall or we part ways?

Good SEO needs input from you: access, approvals, expertise about your business and quick feedback. A good agency tells you what it needs and sets review points, such as a 90-day check-in.

Also ask what you keep if you leave: documentation, content, redirect maps and account access.

  • A good answer: a short list of what they need from you and a clear handoff plan.
  • Red flag: no exit plan, or content and assets that stay with the agency.

Red flags at a glance

Red flagWhy it matters
Guaranteed rankings or "priority submit"Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking
Unsolicited cold email about your siteGoogle advises the same skepticism you'd give any spam offer
Secrecy about what they will doYou're responsible for your agency's actions, and deceptive tactics can get a site removed from Google
Link packages, networks or bulk directoriesThese can violate Google's spam policies
Analytics or profiles in their nameYou could lose your data if you leave
Reports with only rankings or trafficThey can look good while leads fall
Price far below the marketScope or quality is likely cut elsewhere

How do you compare SEO agency proposals?

Send the same 12 questions in writing to two or three agencies and compare the answers side by side. Judge clarity and honesty as much as content, since the agency that explains things plainly is usually the one that will report plainly later.

If an agency offers an audit first, treat it as a low-risk way to see how they think, and keep access limited as Google advises. Be cautious about any audit that ends with a guarantee.

What should the first 90 days look like?

This is our view of a reasonable plan, not a promise of results:

  • Month 1: baseline and plan. Tracking checked, audit completed, goals and priorities agreed.
  • Month 2: foundations. Technical fixes, profile and listing cleanup, and the first priority pages.
  • Month 3: build and review. Content and authority work under way, plus a review of what has been done and what the data shows.

Note - Rankings and leads may move later than this, so judge the first quarter on work delivered and transparency, not on traffic spikes.

How Rizing Metrics answers these questions

At Rizing Metrics, we believe an agency should be able to answer every question on this list in plain language, before you sign anything. Our approach focuses on understanding your business first, then prioritizing what will move the needle and improving over time. We are a Maryland-based agency serving businesses across the United States.

Depending on your situation, our work can include Organic SEO Services, Technical SEO, Local SEO, SEO Content Services, Link Building & Digital PR, Answer Engine Optimization and AI Visibility Optimization. A Website SEO Audit is often the best place to start.

Not ready to talk to anyone yet? Run our free AI Audit to see how your website looks across AI visibility, on-page SEO, performance, local search and technical factors. When you're ready, ask us the same 12 questions. You can contact us or review our pricing first.

Frequently asked questions

How do I choose an SEO agency?

Compare two or three agencies using the same written questions about scope, measurement, expected timeline, references, link building, AI use, account ownership, communication and contract terms. Prefer the one that answers plainly and avoids guarantees.

How much does an SEO agency cost?

It varies by market and scope. Ahrefs' survey of 439 providers found agency retainers averaging about $3,209 a month, with $501 to $2,000 the most common band. Backlinko's survey puts the typical range at $1,000 to $2,500. See our pricing page for ours.

What questions should I ask an SEO company before hiring?

Ask what they'll do each month, whether they guarantee results, how they measure success, what timeline to expect, who they've worked with, how they build links, how they use AI, who owns the accounts, who does the work, what it costs and what happens if you leave.

How long does SEO take to show results?

There's no fixed timeline. Ahrefs found only 1.74% of new pages reached Google's top 10 within a year. Local profile and listing fixes can show effects sooner, but competitive markets take longer. Be wary of anyone promising results by a set date.

Can anyone guarantee first-page rankings?

No. Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking and warns against SEOs claiming a special relationship with Google or offering "priority submit."

What access should I give an SEO agency?

Early on, during an audit, Google advises read-only access to Search Console. Once you've hired them, give the access they need to do the work, but keep your accounts in your own name and ask them to document every change.

Should I sign a long-term SEO contract?

Look closely at minimum terms, notice periods and what you keep if you leave. SEO needs months to work, so some commitment is normal, but you should have a clear review point and a way out. Have a professional review the contract.

What are the red flags of a bad SEO agency?

Guaranteed rankings, secrecy about methods, link packages or bulk directory submissions, accounts held in the agency's name, reports without lead data, unsolicited cold emails and prices far below the market.

Is it worth hiring an SEO agency for a small local business?

Sometimes. Google says small local businesses can do much of the work themselves. An agency helps when you need technical fixes, service pages, content and authority building, and tracking, and don't have the time or skills in-house.

How do I know if my SEO agency is doing a good job?

Look for clear reports tied to calls, leads and booked jobs, a change log of the work done, regular communication and progress against the milestones you agreed. Judge the first months on work delivered, then on results.

What's the difference between an SEO agency, a consultant and a freelancer?

Agencies offer a team across technical, content and authority work. Consultants usually advise and direct. Freelancers often handle specific tasks. In Ahrefs' survey, average monthly retainers were about $3,209 for agencies, $3,250 for consultants and $1,348 for freelancers, but quality and scope matter more than the label.

What should I do if I think an SEO deceived me?

Google's guidance says that in the United States, the Federal Trade Commission handles complaints about deceptive or unfair business practices, which you can file on the FTC website or by calling 1-877-FTC-HELP.

Free 15-minute audit

Ready to fix your AI visibility?

Get a free AI Visibility Audit - we'll show you exactly where ChatGPT and Gemini cite you (or don't).

See how our website SEO audit shows how we think before you commit to anything